sirmax Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 http://forum.worldoftanks.ru/index.php?/topic/134588-%d0%bd%d0%b0%d1%81%d0%ba%d0%be%d0%bb%d1%8c%d0%ba%d0%be-%d0%b2%d0%bb%d0%b8%d1%8f%d0%b5%d1%82-%d1%81%d0%ba%d0%b8%d0%bb-%d0%b8%d0%b3%d1%80%d0%be%d0%ba%d0%b0-%d0%bd%d0%b0-%d1%81%d1%82%d0%b0%d1%82%d0%b8%d1%81%d1%82%d0%b8%d0%ba%d1%83/#top#topСмотри не зачитайся. Потому что на аккаунте нет других похожих танков - видимо любитель нагиба на КВасе даже ИСа не прокачал. Порядок выбора танков для сравнения конечно можно обсуждать и дорабатывать, но для этого нужна более конструктивная критика - по типу: вот у меня есть такой танк и такой, почему вместо них выбрало такой? По адекватности результата, знаешь, я тоже скорее поверю в цифру 51%, чем в цифру 59%, если увижу первую на КТ, а вторую на КВасе. Еще одна тема есть: http://forum.worldoftanks.ru/index.php?/topic/131342-%D0%BA%D0%B0%D0%BA-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%BD%D0%BE-%D0%B8%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%82%D0%B8%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%B0%D1%82%D1%8C-%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82-%D0%BF%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%B4/ Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
tourist Posted December 30, 2012 Author Share Posted December 30, 2012 На данный момент нарисовалась следующая формула достаточного урона: Достаточный урон = D*(0,996+(R-50)*0,0114)*Kt; где, D - среднесерверный урон по группе игроков с близким % побед на этом танке, группы: до 48%, 48-53%, 53-59%, 59-64%, свыше 64% (тут неплохо бы замутить тренд). R - % побед игрока на танке, Кt - коэффициент вида техники, его значения: АРТ 1,1073 ЛТ 1,5672 Мелочь 1,0211 ПТ 1,1112 СТ 1,2092 ТТ 1,0648 Коэффициенты получены скрещиванием выгрузки sirmax'а с таблицей из base.csv посредством симплексного метода. Пока что по некоторой технике получается не очень, но будем дорабатывать. Пример, для ИС-3 с 58% побед: 1372*(0,996+(58-50)*0,0114)*1,0648 = 1588. Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
FromShadow Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 На данный момент нарисовалась следующая формула достаточного урона: Достаточный урон = D*(0,996+(R-50)*0,0114)*Kt; где, D - среднесерверный урон по группе игроков с близким % побед на этом танке, группы: до 48%, 48-53%, 53-59%, 59-64%, свыше 64% (тут неплохо бы замутить тренд). R - % побед игрока на танке, Кt - коэффициент вида техники, его значения: АРТ 1,1073 ЛТ 1,5672 Мелочь 1,0211 ПТ 1,1112 СТ 1,2092 ТТ 1,0648 Коэффициенты получены скрещиванием выгрузки sirmax'а с таблицей из base.csv посредством симплексного метода. Пока что по некоторой технике получается не очень, но будем дорабатывать. Пример, для ИС-3 с 58% побед: 1372*(0,996+(58-50)*0,0114)*1,0648 = 1588. Имхо, процент побед не настолько важный параметр, что бы от него хоть как то зависела формула. Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
tourist Posted December 30, 2012 Author Share Posted December 30, 2012 (edited) Вот по FnB, заодно со скриптами. Большая просьба - закомменть печаталку функции search, заспамила весь лог, невозможно разобраться. Имхо, процент побед не настолько важный параметр, что бы от него хоть как то зависела формула. Ты не понимаешь смысла этой формулы даже приблизительно. Для прояснения можешь графики посмотреть для начала - на 4-й странице этой темы. Edited December 30, 2012 by tourist Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
FromShadow Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 Ты не понимаешь смысла этой формулы даже приблизительно. Для прояснения можешь графики посмотреть для начала - на 4-й странице этой темы. Верно, я все еще не понимаю ваш главный тезис: основной показатель умения играть - % побед Графики не несут прояснения ровно никакого. С таким же успехом можно построить зависимость урона от очков захвата базы. Что то оно покажет, а толку ноль. Конкретно же по вашим графикам, то танк никак не меняется с увеличением процента побед. Это не рпг, где если больше лвл у персонажа - значит он сильнее. Танки статичны, значит нужна и планка статичная. Для того же ис3 планка в 1500 урона должна быть вообще минимальной, т.к. он вполне позволяет наносить и 2к+ урона за бой. 1372*(0,996+(58-50)*0,0114)*1,0648 = 1588. 1372*(0,996+(50-50)*0,0114)*1,0648= 1455. К чему это вообще? Имея 50%, человек уже играет лучше чем большая часть сервера, так пусть и дамажит соответственно, нафига брать заниженные показатели? Что бы нубы считали, что они играют круто и не стремились к развитию? Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
TurinDeNar Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 (edited) Верно, я все еще не понимаю ваш главный тезис: Графики не несут прояснения ровно никакого. С таким же успехом можно построить зависимость урона от очков захвата базы. Что то оно покажет, а толку ноль. Конкретно же по вашим графикам, то танк никак не меняется с увеличением процента побед. Это не рпг, где если больше лвл у персонажа - значит он сильнее. Танки статичны, значит нужна и планка статичная. Для того же ис3 планка в 1500 урона должна быть вообще минимальной, т.к. он вполне позволяет наносить и 2к+ урона за бой. 1372*(0,996+(58-50)*0,0114)*1,0648 = 1588. 1372*(0,996+(50-50)*0,0114)*1,0648= 1455. К чему это вообще? Имея 50%, человек уже играет лучше чем большая часть сервера, так пусть и дамажит соответственно, нафига брать заниженные показатели? Что бы нубы считали, что они играют круто и не стремились к развитию? FromShadow, основная цель данного калькулятора показать реальный скил игрока выраженный в проценте побед как если бы он играл чисто солорандом. Другими словами, если игрок имеет на ИС-3 70% побед и всего 1500 дамага, то понятно что такой большой процент он набил в ротах взводах а никак не соло с таким дамагом, и калькулятор скорректирует ему его реальный процент побед до 55%. А если игрок соло при 55% будет иметь дамаг 1500 то калькулятор ему ничего и не скорректирует, при условии что на других примерно похожих танках картинка будет примерно такая же. Ну это если в целом, а еще много есть других оговорок. Стата в целом по акку также будет скорреткирована также в том случае, когда игрок имеет на нем 70% общих побед но набитых на танках 1-3 лвл. Edited December 30, 2012 by TurinDeNar Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
tourist Posted December 30, 2012 Author Share Posted December 30, 2012 (edited) Верно, я все еще не понимаю ваш главный тезис: Ну с этим ты можешь идти в темы про статистику - выше давали ссылки. Тут же оно просто неинтересно. 1372*(0,996+(58-50)*0,0114)*1,0648 = 1588.1372*(0,996+(50-50)*0,0114)*1,0648= 1455. К чему это вообще? Имея 50%, человек уже играет лучше чем большая часть сервера, так пусть и дамажит соответственно, нафига брать заниженные показатели? Что бы нубы считали, что они играют круто и не стремились к развитию? Честно говоря, формула пока что херовая, так сказать - пробный блин. Но брать один и тот же урон для всех игроков - просто бред и не отвечает поставленной задаче. Нам нужна шкала для выявления ротно-взводных товарищей с высоким % побед, поэтому подход - нанес 1500 урона, значит молодец - не годится. Edited December 30, 2012 by tourist Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
sirmax Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 (edited) Большая просьба - закомменть печаталку функции search, заспамила весь лог, невозможно разобраться. grep? Вот без search: WARNING: No data in base.csv for T54E1 WARNING: No data in base.csv for T69 Battles: 21450 DEBUG: Deleted: b=186 %=51 PzVI DEBUG: Deleted: b=112 %=51 SU-100 DEBUG: Deleted: b=101 %=52 StuGIII DEBUG: Deleted: b=144 %=53 SU-8 Calculating Begin for T110 88.4615 0.5 0.4803 Similar tanks: GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 M103 62.4021 IS-7 77.8626 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Check other tank Begin for GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 1 0.5864 Similar tanks: M103 62.4021 GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 T110 88.4615 See other tank M103 62.4021 Check other tank Begin for M103 62.4021 1 1.0292 Return cutted rate for M103: 62.4021 See other tank GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 Check other tank Begin for GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 0.8 0.5977 Similar tanks: T32 74.3802 GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 M103 62.4021 See other tank T32 74.3802 Check other tank Begin for T32 74.3802 0.7 0.7960 Return cutted rate for T32: 67.2046 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Check other tank Begin for GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 1 0.5864 Return cutted rate for GB12_Conqueror: 78.1341 See other tank M103 62.4021 Add good rate for GB11_Caernarvon: 62.4021 Return middle rate of GB11_Caernarvon: 69.82 See other tank T110 88.4615 Check other tank Begin for T110 88.4615 0.5 0.4803 Similar tanks: GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 M103 62.4021 IS-7 77.8626 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for T110: 78.1341 See other tank M103 62.4021 Add good rate for T110: 62.4021 See other tank IS-7 77.8626 Check other tank Begin for IS-7 77.8626 0.6 0.5423 Similar tanks: IS8 58.1858 T110 88.4615 F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 See other tank IS8 58.1858 Check other tank Begin for IS8 58.1858 1 1.1122 Return cutted rate for IS8: 58.1858 See other tank T110 88.4615 Check other tank Begin for T110 88.4615 0.5 0.4803 Similar tanks: GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 M103 62.4021 IS-7 77.8626 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for T110: 78.1341 See other tank M103 62.4021 Add good rate for T110: 62.4021 See other tank IS-7 77.8626 Check other tank Begin for IS-7 77.8626 0.6 0.5423 Return cutted rate for IS-7: 63.4952 Return middle rate of T110: 67.55 See other tank F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 Check other tank Begin for F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 0.8 0.7102 Return cutted rate for F10_AMX_50B: 74.7384 Return middle rate of IS-7: 65.99 Return middle rate of T110: 68.18 Return middle rate of GB12_Conqueror: 69.63 See other tank M103 62.4021 Add good rate for T110: 62.4021 See other tank IS-7 77.8626 Add good rate for T110: 65.9930 Return middle rate of T110: 66.05 Begin for E-50 72.6426 1 0.7494 Similar tanks: Lorraine40t 86.7021 Panther_II 57.1429 M46_Patton 84.3810 See other tank Lorraine40t 86.7021 Check other tank Begin for Lorraine40t 86.7021 0.8 0.5779 Similar tanks: Panther_II 57.1429 E-50 72.6426 M46_Patton 84.3810 See other tank Panther_II 57.1429 Check other tank Begin for Panther_II 57.1429 1 0.8894 Return cutted rate for Panther_II: 56.3633 See other tank E-50 72.6426 Check other tank Begin for E-50 72.6426 1 0.7494 Return cutted rate for E-50: 68.3971 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Check other tank Begin for M46_Patton 84.3810 1 0.4412 Similar tanks: Pershing 70.4036 GB23_Centurion 76.8116 Lorraine40t 86.7021 See other tank Pershing 70.4036 Check other tank Begin for Pershing 70.4036 0.8 0.7973 Return cutted rate for Pershing: 65.2834 See other tank GB23_Centurion 76.8116 Check other tank Begin for GB23_Centurion 76.8116 0.9 0.8980 Return cutted rate for GB23_Centurion: 73.5927 See other tank Lorraine40t 86.7021 Check other tank Begin for Lorraine40t 86.7021 0.8 0.5779 Return cutted rate for Lorraine40t: 72.6857 Return middle rate of M46_Patton: 70.61 Return middle rate of Lorraine40t: 67.02 See other tank Panther_II 57.1429 Add good rate for E-50: 56.3633 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for E-50: 70.6139 Return middle rate of E-50: 65.60 Begin for KV-5 79.4667 1 0.6042 Similar tanks: VK4502P 61.2000 E-75 78.3133 GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Check other tank Begin for VK4502P 61.2000 1 0.9304 Return cutted rate for VK4502P: 60.5087 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Check other tank Begin for E-75 78.3133 0.9 0.6663 Similar tanks: VK4502P 61.2000 GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 E-100 82.8829 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Add good rate for E-75: 60.5087 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for E-75: 69.6339 See other tank E-100 82.8829 Check other tank Begin for E-100 82.8829 1 0.3625 Similar tanks: E-75 78.3133 VK4502P 61.2000 GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Check other tank Begin for E-75 78.3133 0.9 0.6663 Return cutted rate for E-75: 70.2102 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Add good rate for E-100: 60.5087 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for E-100: 69.6339 Return middle rate of E-100: 66.91 Return middle rate of E-75: 66.82 See other tank GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 Add good rate for KV-5: 69.8227 Return middle rate of KV-5: 67.17 Begin for T-54 82.1918 0.8 0.4440 Similar tanks: Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 M46_Patton 84.3810 See other tank Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Check other tank Begin for Ch01_Type59 75.3709 1 0.7966 Return cutted rate for Ch01_Type59: 71.7837 See other tank Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 Check other tank Begin for Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 0.7 0.6331 Similar tanks: T-54 82.1918 Lorraine40t 86.7021 M46_Patton 84.3810 See other tank T-54 82.1918 Check other tank Begin for T-54 82.1918 0.8 0.4440 Similar tanks: Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 M46_Patton 84.3810 See other tank Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Add good rate for T-54: 71.7837 See other tank Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 Check other tank Begin for Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 0.7 0.6331 Return cutted rate for Bat_Chatillon25t: 67.8068 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for T-54: 70.6139 Return middle rate of T-54: 69.21 See other tank Lorraine40t 86.7021 Add good rate for Bat_Chatillon25t: 67.0150 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for Bat_Chatillon25t: 70.6139 Return middle rate of Bat_Chatillon25t: 68.66 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for T-54: 70.6139 Return middle rate of T-54: 69.42 Begin for IS-3 67.7321 0.3 0.7525 Similar tanks: T32 74.3802 IS 54.9223 T29 66.6667 See other tank T32 74.3802 Add good rate for IS-3: 67.2046 See other tank IS 54.9223 Check other tank Begin for IS 54.9223 1 0.9081 Return cutted rate for IS: 54.4221 See other tank T29 66.6667 Check other tank Begin for T29 66.6667 1 0.7122 Return cutted rate for T29: 63.2470 Return middle rate of IS-3: 60.67 Begin for Object_212 80.3175 1 0.5079 Similar tanks: G_Tiger 79.8450 SU-14 70.2206 G_E 87.8906 See other tank G_Tiger 79.8450 Check other tank Begin for G_Tiger 79.8450 1 0.5083 Similar tanks: G_E 87.8906 Object_212 80.3175 M40M43 88.9412 See other tank G_E 87.8906 Check other tank Begin for G_E 87.8906 0.5 0.3218 Similar tanks: G_Tiger 79.8450 Object_212 80.3175 M40M43 88.9412 See other tank G_Tiger 79.8450 Check other tank Begin for G_Tiger 79.8450 1 0.5083 Return cutted rate for G_Tiger: 70.4491 See other tank Object_212 80.3175 Check other tank Begin for Object_212 80.3175 1 0.5079 Return cutted rate for Object_212: 70.7865 See other tank M40M43 88.9412 Check other tank Begin for M40M43 88.9412 1 0.4659 Return cutted rate for M40M43: 76.0702 Return middle rate of G_E: 69.83 See other tank Object_212 80.3175 Add good rate for G_Tiger: 70.7865 See other tank M40M43 88.9412 Add good rate for G_Tiger: 76.0702 Return middle rate of G_Tiger: 71.78 See other tank SU-14 70.2206 Check other tank Begin for SU-14 70.2206 1 0.7578 Return cutted rate for SU-14: 67.0683 See other tank G_E 87.8906 Add good rate for Object_212: 69.8280 Return middle rate of Object_212: 69.87 Begin for F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 0.8 0.7102 Return good rate for F10_AMX_50B: 74.7384 Begin for M46_Patton 84.3810 1 0.4412 Return good rate for M46_Patton: 70.6139 Begin for IS-7 77.8626 0.6 0.5423 Return good rate for IS-7: 65.9930 Begin for ISU-152 57.8035 1 0.8327 Return cutted rate for ISU-152: 56.5594 Begin for KV1 61.1789 0.8 1.0891 Return cutted rate for KV1: 60.2067 Begin for Hummel 59.9174 1 0.9457 Return cutted rate for Hummel: 59.5254 Begin for Ferdinand 73.7527 1 0.7955 Similar tanks: JagdTiger 66.3636 ISU-152 57.8035 T30 74.7312 See other tank JagdTiger 66.3636 Check other tank Begin for JagdTiger 66.3636 1 0.8163 Return cutted rate for JagdTiger: 63.9587 See other tank ISU-152 57.8035 Add good rate for Ferdinand: 56.5594 See other tank T30 74.7312 Check other tank Begin for T30 74.7312 1 0.7508 Return cutted rate for T30: 70.1898 Return middle rate of Ferdinand: 65.26 Begin for IS8 58.1858 1 1.1122 Return good rate for IS8: 58.1858 Begin for Maus 92.6009 1 0.2895 Similar tanks: E-100 82.8829 VK4502P 61.2000 E-75 78.3133 See other tank E-100 82.8829 Add good rate for Maus: 66.9135 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Add good rate for Maus: 60.5087 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Add good rate for Maus: 66.8166 Return middle rate of Maus: 66.26 Begin for T-44 70.2079 0.9 0.7593 Similar tanks: Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Pershing 70.4036 T-43 56.9343 See other tank Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Add good rate for T-44: 71.7837 See other tank Pershing 70.4036 Add good rate for T-44: 65.2834 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Check other tank Begin for T-43 56.9343 1 0.6447 Return cutted rate for T-43: 54.6087 Return middle rate of T-44: 64.33 Begin for M40M43 88.9412 1 0.4659 Return good rate for M40M43: 76.0702 Begin for PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.9558 1 0.7277 Similar tanks: GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 T32 74.3802 GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 See other tank GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 Add good rate for PzVIB_Tiger_II: 69.8227 See other tank T32 74.3802 Add good rate for PzVIB_Tiger_II: 67.2046 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for PzVIB_Tiger_II: 69.6339 Return middle rate of PzVIB_Tiger_II: 69.01 Begin for Object_704 73.3161 1 0.8095 Similar tanks: T30 74.7312 JagdTiger 66.3636 AMX50_Foch 89.2617 See other tank T30 74.7312 Add good rate for Object_704: 70.1898 See other tank JagdTiger 66.3636 Add good rate for Object_704: 63.9587 See other tank AMX50_Foch 89.2617 Check other tank Begin for AMX50_Foch 89.2617 1 0.5740 Similar tanks: AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 Object_704 73.3161 T30 74.7312 See other tank AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 Check other tank Begin for AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 1 0.7558 Return cutted rate for AMX_AC_Mle1948: 69.5929 See other tank Object_704 73.3161 Check other tank Begin for Object_704 73.3161 1 0.8095 Return cutted rate for Object_704: 70.0096 See other tank T30 74.7312 Add good rate for AMX50_Foch: 70.1898 Return middle rate of AMX50_Foch: 71.87 Return middle rate of Object_704: 69.01 Begin for M103 62.4021 1 1.0292 Return good rate for M103: 62.4021 Begin for S-51 66.9421 0.8 0.8145 Similar tanks: M12 53.6481 M40M43 88.9412 Object_212 80.3175 See other tank M12 53.6481 Check other tank Begin for M12 53.6481 0.8 1.2342 Return cutted rate for M12: 53.6481 See other tank M40M43 88.9412 Add good rate for S-51: 76.0702 See other tank Object_212 80.3175 Add good rate for S-51: 69.8666 Return middle rate of S-51: 65.58 Begin for M48A1 81.9945 0.8 0.6110 Similar tanks: T-54 82.1918 M46_Patton 84.3810 Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 See other tank T-54 82.1918 Add good rate for M48A1: 69.4243 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for M48A1: 70.6139 See other tank Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 Add good rate for M48A1: 68.6616 Return middle rate of M48A1: 69.70 Begin for Ch01_Type59 75.3709 1 0.7966 Return good rate for Ch01_Type59: 71.7837 Begin for AMX_50_120 84.2623 1 0.6746 Similar tanks: F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 IS8 58.1858 AMX_50_100 83.2432 See other tank F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 Add good rate for AMX_50_120: 74.7384 See other tank IS8 58.1858 Add good rate for AMX_50_120: 58.1858 See other tank AMX_50_100 83.2432 Check other tank Begin for AMX_50_100 83.2432 0.8 0.6157 Similar tanks: IS8 58.1858 AMX_50_120 84.2623 IS-3 67.7321 See other tank IS8 58.1858 Add good rate for AMX_50_100: 58.1858 See other tank AMX_50_120 84.2623 Check other tank Begin for AMX_50_120 84.2623 1 0.6746 Return cutted rate for AMX_50_120: 76.4309 See other tank IS-3 67.7321 Add good rate for AMX_50_100: 60.6664 Return middle rate of AMX_50_100: 66.70 Return middle rate of AMX_50_120: 69.01 Begin for Lorraine155_51 78.7004 1 0.7513 Similar tanks: Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 Lorraine155_50 74.5455 G_Panther 54.3307 See other tank Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 Check other tank Begin for Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 0.6 0.6678 Similar tanks: Lorraine155_51 78.7004 Lorraine155_50 74.5455 G_Panther 54.3307 See other tank Lorraine155_51 78.7004 Check other tank Begin for Lorraine155_51 78.7004 1 0.7513 Return cutted rate for Lorraine155_51: 74.1038 See other tank Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Check other tank Begin for Lorraine155_50 74.5455 0.5 0.7644 Similar tanks: G_Panther 54.3307 Lorraine155_51 78.7004 Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 See other tank G_Panther 54.3307 Check other tank Begin for G_Panther 54.3307 0.5 1.3510 Return cutted rate for G_Panther: 53.7635 See other tank Lorraine155_51 78.7004 Add good rate for Lorraine155_50: 74.1038 See other tank Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 Check other tank Begin for Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 0.6 0.6678 Return cutted rate for Bat_Chatillon155: 70.8536 Return middle rate of Lorraine155_50: 65.63 See other tank G_Panther 54.3307 Add good rate for Bat_Chatillon155: 53.7635 Return middle rate of Bat_Chatillon155: 66.09 See other tank Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Add good rate for Lorraine155_51: 65.6314 See other tank G_Panther 54.3307 Add good rate for Lorraine155_51: 53.7635 Return middle rate of Lorraine155_51: 64.90 Begin for SU-14 70.2206 1 0.7578 Return good rate for SU-14: 67.0683 Begin for ARL_44 89.6552 0.6 0.3661 Similar tanks: KV1 61.1789 T29 66.6667 T32 74.3802 See other tank KV1 61.1789 Add good rate for ARL_44: 60.2067 See other tank T29 66.6667 Add good rate for ARL_44: 63.2470 See other tank T32 74.3802 Add good rate for ARL_44: 67.2046 Return middle rate of ARL_44: 64.26 Begin for G_Tiger 79.8450 1 0.5083 Return good rate for G_Tiger: 71.7835 Begin for G_E 87.8906 0.5 0.3218 Return good rate for G_E: 69.8280 Begin for G_Panther 54.3307 0.5 1.3510 Return good rate for G_Panther: 53.7635 Begin for Panther_II 57.1429 1 0.8894 Return good rate for Panther_II: 56.3633 Begin for VK4502P 61.2000 1 0.9304 Return good rate for VK4502P: 60.5087 Begin for GB24_Centurion_Mk3 83.4008 1 0.6182 Similar tanks: GB23_Centurion 76.8116 M46_Patton 84.3810 Lorraine40t 86.7021 See other tank GB23_Centurion 76.8116 Add good rate for GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 73.5927 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 70.6139 See other tank Lorraine40t 86.7021 Add good rate for GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 67.0150 Return middle rate of GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 71.41 Begin for T32 74.3802 0.7 0.7960 Return good rate for T32: 67.2046 Begin for M12 53.6481 0.8 1.2342 Return good rate for M12: 53.6481 Begin for Pershing 70.4036 0.8 0.7973 Return good rate for Pershing: 65.2834 Begin for Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 0.7 0.6331 Return good rate for Bat_Chatillon25t: 68.6616 Begin for T29 66.6667 1 0.7122 Return good rate for T29: 63.2470 Begin for T28 72.4490 1 0.6476 Similar tanks: Ferdinand 73.7527 T95 64.4860 JagdTiger 66.3636 See other tank Ferdinand 73.7527 Add good rate for T28: 65.2616 See other tank T95 64.4860 Check other tank Begin for T95 64.4860 1 0.6930 Return cutted rate for T95: 60.8200 See other tank JagdTiger 66.3636 Add good rate for T28: 63.9587 Return middle rate of T28: 64.22 Begin for IS 54.9223 1 0.9081 Return good rate for IS: 54.4221 Begin for SU-101 62.5000 1 0.9995 Return cutted rate for SU-101: 62.4945 Begin for SU-152 59.7884 1 0.8176 Return cutted rate for SU-152: 58.3094 Begin for JagdPanther 59.5745 1 0.9993 Return cutted rate for JagdPanther: 59.5690 Begin for Lorraine40t 86.7021 0.8 0.5779 Return good rate for Lorraine40t: 67.0150 Begin for T30 74.7312 1 0.7508 Return good rate for T30: 70.1898 Begin for AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 1 0.7558 Return good rate for AMX_AC_Mle1948: 69.5929 Begin for AMX_50_100 83.2432 0.8 0.6157 Return good rate for AMX_50_100: 66.6962 Begin for GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 1 0.5864 Return good rate for GB12_Conqueror: 69.6339 Begin for M41 64.1618 1 0.9682 Return cutted rate for M41: 63.8671 Begin for VK3002DB 67.6647 1 0.5747 Similar tanks: T20 63.2653 T-43 56.9343 Ch01_Type59 75.3709 See other tank T20 63.2653 Check other tank Begin for T20 63.2653 1 0.8682 Return cutted rate for T20: 61.9450 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Add good rate for VK3002DB: 54.6087 See other tank Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Add good rate for VK3002DB: 71.7837 Return middle rate of VK3002DB: 62.68 Begin for E-75 78.3133 0.9 0.6663 Return good rate for E-75: 66.8166 Begin for Lorraine155_50 74.5455 0.5 0.7644 Return good rate for Lorraine155_50: 65.6314 Begin for AMX50_Foch 89.2617 1 0.5740 Return good rate for AMX50_Foch: 71.8746 Begin for T20 63.2653 1 0.8682 Return good rate for T20: 61.9450 Begin for VK1602 68.2759 0.8 0.4846 Similar tanks: T_50_2 66.6667 T-50 76.9841 M5_Stuart 65.1786 See other tank T_50_2 66.6667 Check other tank Begin for T_50_2 66.6667 0.3 0.5828 Similar tanks: M24_Chaffee 80.7692 VK1602 68.2759 T-50 76.9841 See other tank M24_Chaffee 80.7692 Check other tank Begin for M24_Chaffee 80.7692 1 0.7381 Return cutted rate for M24_Chaffee: 76.2367 See other tank VK1602 68.2759 Check other tank Begin for VK1602 68.2759 0.8 0.4846 Similar tanks: T_50_2 66.6667 T-50 76.9841 M5_Stuart 65.1786 See other tank T_50_2 66.6667 Check other tank Begin for T_50_2 66.6667 0.3 0.5828 Similar tanks: M24_Chaffee 80.7692 VK1602 68.2759 T-50 76.9841 See other tank M24_Chaffee 80.7692 Add good rate for T_50_2: 76.2367 See other tank VK1602 68.2759 Check other tank Begin for VK1602 68.2759 0.8 0.4846 Return cutted rate for VK1602: 60.3054 See other tank T-50 76.9841 Check other tank Begin for T-50 76.9841 0.3 0.5351 Similar tanks: M5_Stuart 65.1786 VK1602 68.2759 M24_Chaffee 80.7692 See other tank M5_Stuart 65.1786 Check other tank Begin for M5_Stuart 65.1786 0.8 1.8061 Return cutted rate for M5_Stuart: 65.1786 See other tank VK1602 68.2759 Add good rate for T-50: 60.3054 See other tank M24_Chaffee 80.7692 Add good rate for T-50: 76.2367 Return middle rate of T-50: 64.93 Return middle rate of T_50_2: 63.98 See other tank T-50 76.9841 Add good rate for VK1602: 64.9279 See other tank M5_Stuart 65.1786 Add good rate for VK1602: 65.1786 Return middle rate of VK1602: 63.60 See other tank T-50 76.9841 Add good rate for T_50_2: 64.9279 Return middle rate of T_50_2: 64.81 See other tank T-50 76.9841 Add good rate for VK1602: 64.9279 See other tank M5_Stuart 65.1786 Add good rate for VK1602: 65.1786 Return middle rate of VK1602: 63.80 Begin for GB23_Centurion 76.8116 0.9 0.8980 Return good rate for GB23_Centurion: 73.5927 Begin for T-43 56.9343 1 0.6447 Return good rate for T-43: 54.6087 Begin for AMX_13F3AM 75.7576 1 0.7093 Similar tanks: M41 64.1618 Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Hummel 59.9174 See other tank M41 64.1618 Add good rate for AMX_13F3AM: 63.8671 See other tank Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Add good rate for AMX_13F3AM: 65.6314 See other tank Hummel 59.9174 Add good rate for AMX_13F3AM: 59.5254 Return middle rate of AMX_13F3AM: 65.11 Begin for JagdPzIV 55.8140 1 0.8086 Return cutted rate for JagdPzIV: 54.7455 Begin for M18_Hellcat 74.4186 0.5 0.7173 Similar tanks: T25_2 59.2233 JagdPanther 59.5745 JagdPzIV 55.8140 See other tank T25_2 59.2233 Check other tank Begin for T25_2 59.2233 1 1.4583 Return cutted rate for T25_2: 59.2233 See other tank JagdPanther 59.5745 Add good rate for M18_Hellcat: 59.5690 See other tank JagdPzIV 55.8140 Add good rate for M18_Hellcat: 54.7455 Return middle rate of M18_Hellcat: 59.14 Begin for T-50 76.9841 0.3 0.5351 Return good rate for T-50: 64.9279 Begin for VK3601H 57.9832 0.7 0.8503 Similar tanks: VK3001P 53.2710 T-34-85 67.3077 T-43 56.9343 See other tank VK3001P 53.2710 Check other tank Begin for VK3001P 53.2710 0.8 0.8555 Return cutted rate for VK3001P: 51.8538 See other tank T-34-85 67.3077 Check other tank Begin for T-34-85 67.3077 0.7 0.6243 Similar tanks: VK3001P 53.2710 T-43 56.9343 T20 63.2653 See other tank VK3001P 53.2710 Add good rate for T-34-85: 51.8538 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Add good rate for T-34-85: 54.6087 See other tank T20 63.2653 Add good rate for T-34-85: 61.9450 Return middle rate of T-34-85: 57.04 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Add good rate for VK3601H: 54.6087 Return middle rate of VK3601H: 54.65 Begin for GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 0.8 0.5977 Return good rate for GB11_Caernarvon: 69.8227 Begin for T_50_2 66.6667 0.3 0.5828 Return good rate for T_50_2: 64.8070 Begin for M5_Stuart 65.1786 0.8 1.8061 Return good rate for M5_Stuart: 65.1786 Begin for E-100 82.8829 1 0.3625 Return good rate for E-100: 66.9135 Begin for JagdTiger 66.3636 1 0.8163 Return good rate for JagdTiger: 63.9587 Begin for T95 64.4860 1 0.6930 Return good rate for T95: 60.8200 Begin for VK3001P 53.2710 0.8 0.8555 Return good rate for VK3001P: 51.8538 Begin for T-34-85 67.3077 0.7 0.6243 Return good rate for T-34-85: 57.0378 Begin for M24_Chaffee 80.7692 1 0.7381 Return good rate for M24_Chaffee: 76.2367 Begin for T25_2 59.2233 1 1.4583 Return good rate for T25_2: 59.2233 Begin for Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 0.6 0.6678 Return good rate for Bat_Chatillon155: 66.0881 Begin winrate is: 73.78 rate T-rate Ka Kd Tank 88.46 66.05 0.5000 0.4803 T110 72.64 65.60 1.0000 0.7494 E-50 79.47 67.17 1.0000 0.6042 KV-5 82.19 69.42 0.8000 0.4440 T-54 67.73 60.67 0.3000 0.7525 IS-3 80.32 69.87 1.0000 0.5079 Object_212 85.07 74.74 0.8000 0.7102 F10_AMX_50B 84.38 70.61 1.0000 0.4412 M46_Patton 77.86 65.99 0.6000 0.5423 IS-7 57.80 56.56 1.0000 0.8327 ISU-152 61.18 60.21 0.8000 1.0891 KV1 59.92 59.53 1.0000 0.9457 Hummel 73.75 65.26 1.0000 0.7955 Ferdinand 58.19 58.19 1.0000 1.1122 IS8 92.60 66.26 1.0000 0.2895 Maus 70.21 64.33 0.9000 0.7593 T-44 88.94 76.07 1.0000 0.4659 M40M43 73.96 69.01 1.0000 0.7277 PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.32 69.01 1.0000 0.8095 Object_704 62.40 62.40 1.0000 1.0292 M103 66.94 65.58 0.8000 0.8145 S-51 81.99 69.70 0.8000 0.6110 M48A1 75.37 71.78 1.0000 0.7966 Ch01_Type59 84.26 69.01 1.0000 0.6746 AMX_50_120 78.70 64.90 1.0000 0.7513 Lorraine155_51 70.22 67.07 1.0000 0.7578 SU-14 89.66 64.26 0.6000 0.3661 ARL_44 79.84 71.78 1.0000 0.5083 G_Tiger 87.89 69.83 0.5000 0.3218 G_E 54.33 53.76 0.5000 1.3510 G_Panther 57.14 56.36 1.0000 0.8894 Panther_II 61.20 60.51 1.0000 0.9304 VK4502P 83.40 71.41 1.0000 0.6182 GB24_Centurion_Mk3 74.38 67.20 0.7000 0.7960 T32 53.65 53.65 0.8000 1.2342 M12 70.40 65.28 0.8000 0.7973 Pershing 79.72 68.66 0.7000 0.6331 Bat_Chatillon25t 66.67 63.25 1.0000 0.7122 T29 72.45 64.22 1.0000 0.6476 T28 54.92 54.42 1.0000 0.9081 IS 62.50 62.49 1.0000 0.9995 SU-101 59.79 58.31 1.0000 0.8176 SU-152 59.57 59.57 1.0000 0.9993 JagdPanther 86.70 67.02 0.8000 0.5779 Lorraine40t 74.73 70.19 1.0000 0.7508 T30 73.66 69.59 1.0000 0.7558 AMX_AC_Mle1948 83.24 66.70 0.8000 0.6157 AMX_50_100 89.39 69.63 1.0000 0.5864 GB12_Conqueror 64.16 63.87 1.0000 0.9682 M41 67.66 62.68 1.0000 0.5747 VK3002DB 78.31 66.82 0.9000 0.6663 E-75 74.55 65.63 0.5000 0.7644 Lorraine155_50 89.26 71.87 1.0000 0.5740 AMX50_Foch 63.27 61.94 1.0000 0.8682 T20 68.28 63.80 0.8000 0.4846 VK1602 76.81 73.59 0.9000 0.8980 GB23_Centurion 56.93 54.61 1.0000 0.6447 T-43 75.76 65.11 1.0000 0.7093 AMX_13F3AM 55.81 54.75 1.0000 0.8086 JagdPzIV 74.42 59.14 0.5000 0.7173 M18_Hellcat 76.98 64.93 0.3000 0.5351 T-50 57.98 54.65 0.7000 0.8503 VK3601H 83.90 69.82 0.8000 0.5977 GB11_Caernarvon 66.67 64.81 0.3000 0.5828 T_50_2 65.18 65.18 0.8000 1.8061 M5_Stuart 82.88 66.91 1.0000 0.3625 E-100 66.36 63.96 1.0000 0.8163 JagdTiger 64.49 60.82 1.0000 0.6930 T95 53.27 51.85 0.8000 0.8555 VK3001P 67.31 57.04 0.7000 0.6243 T-34-85 80.77 76.24 1.0000 0.7381 M24_Chaffee 59.22 59.22 1.0000 1.4583 T25_2 85.44 66.09 0.6000 0.6678 Bat_Chatillon155 Corrected winrate is: 65.30 Duration: 59ms По скорости работы проблем вроде нет, из этих 59 мсек в основном лог все время сожрал. Как я понимаю, сейчас основная проблема - это кривой дамаг, который отдает WG. Edited December 30, 2012 by sirmax Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
nemoW Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 А из клиента в чужих профилях правильная инфа видна или нет? Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
jage Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 а WG вообще собирается инфу по дамагу давать или теперь как на евро серваке будет Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
tourist Posted December 30, 2012 Author Share Posted December 30, 2012 а WG вообще собирается инфу по дамагу давать или теперь как на евро серваке будет Кстати, первоначально данный расчет планировалось делать без дамага, так что если его закроют - переживем. Просто там сложнее алгоритм и меньше точность получится. Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
nemoW Posted December 30, 2012 Share Posted December 30, 2012 Дядя Макс, неужели у вас нет знакомых, через которых можно поинтересоваться у админов WG, что с статистикой на серверах? Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
tourist Posted January 2, 2013 Author Share Posted January 2, 2013 (edited) Begin for T110 88.4615 0.5 0.4803 Similar tanks: GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 M103 62.4021 IS-7 77.8626 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Check other tank Begin for GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 1 0.5864 Similar tanks: M103 62.4021 GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 T110 88.4615 Ошибка в самом начале - считает танки через самих себя. Посмотри использование переменной base[].stack в моем коде. До завершения расчета Т110 этот танк не должен браться для сравнения ни на каких уровнях. Как я понимаю, сейчас основная проблема - это кривой дамаг, который отдает WG. Хотелось бы конечно знать - временное это явление или новая политика ВГ. Иначе может получиться, что все хитрые формулы с дамагом пойдут на свалку. Edited January 2, 2013 by tourist Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
sirmax Posted January 2, 2013 Share Posted January 2, 2013 Ошибка в самом начале - считает танки через самих себя. Посмотри использование переменной base[].stack в моем коде. До завершения расчета Т110 этот танк не должен браться для сравнения ни на каких уровнях. Добавил проверку: WARNING: No data in base.csv for T54E1WARNING: No data in base.csv for T69 Battles: 21450DEBUG: Deleted: b=186 %=51 PzVI DEBUG: Deleted: b=112 %=51 SU-100 DEBUG: Deleted: b=101 %=52 StuGIII DEBUG: Deleted: b=144 %=53 SU-8Calculating Begin for T110 88.4615 0.5 0.4803 Similar tanks: GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 M103 62.4021 IS-7 77.8626 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Check other tank Begin for GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 1 0.5864 Similar tanks: M103 62.4021 GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 E-75 78.3133 See other tank M103 62.4021 Check other tank Begin for M103 62.4021 1 1.0292 Return cutted rate for M103: 62.4021 See other tank GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 Check other tank Begin for GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 0.8 0.5977 Similar tanks: T32 74.3802 M103 62.4021 PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.9558 See other tank T32 74.3802 Check other tank Begin for T32 74.3802 0.7 0.7960 Return cutted rate for T32: 67.2046 See other tank M103 62.4021 Add good rate for GB11_Caernarvon: 62.4021 See other tank PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.9558 Check other tank Begin for PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.9558 1 0.7277 Return cutted rate for PzVIB_Tiger_II: 69.3771 Return middle rate of GB11_Caernarvon: 67.63 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Check other tank Begin for E-75 78.3133 0.9 0.6663 Return cutted rate for E-75: 70.2102 Return middle rate of GB12_Conqueror: 69.59 See other tank M103 62.4021 Add good rate for T110: 62.4021 See other tank IS-7 77.8626 Check other tank Begin for IS-7 77.8626 0.6 0.5423 Similar tanks: IS8 58.1858 F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 See other tank IS8 58.1858 Check other tank Begin for IS8 58.1858 1 1.1122 Return cutted rate for IS8: 58.1858 See other tank F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 Check other tank Begin for F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 0.8 0.7102 Return cutted rate for F10_AMX_50B: 74.7384 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for IS-7: 69.5950 Return middle rate of IS-7: 66.50 Return middle rate of T110: 66.17 Begin for E-50 72.6426 1 0.7494 Similar tanks: Lorraine40t 86.7021 Panther_II 57.1429 M46_Patton 84.3810 See other tank Lorraine40t 86.7021 Check other tank Begin for Lorraine40t 86.7021 0.8 0.5779 Similar tanks: Panther_II 57.1429 M46_Patton 84.3810 Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 See other tank Panther_II 57.1429 Check other tank Begin for Panther_II 57.1429 1 0.8894 Return cutted rate for Panther_II: 56.3633 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Check other tank Begin for M46_Patton 84.3810 1 0.4412 Similar tanks: Pershing 70.4036 GB23_Centurion 76.8116 T-54 82.1918 See other tank Pershing 70.4036 Check other tank Begin for Pershing 70.4036 0.8 0.7973 Return cutted rate for Pershing: 65.2834 See other tank GB23_Centurion 76.8116 Check other tank Begin for GB23_Centurion 76.8116 0.9 0.8980 Return cutted rate for GB23_Centurion: 73.5927 See other tank T-54 82.1918 Check other tank Begin for T-54 82.1918 0.8 0.4440 Similar tanks: Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 T-44 70.2079 See other tank Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Check other tank Begin for Ch01_Type59 75.3709 1 0.7966 Return cutted rate for Ch01_Type59: 71.7837 See other tank Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 Check other tank Begin for Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 0.7 0.6331 Return cutted rate for Bat_Chatillon25t: 67.8068 See other tank T-44 70.2079 Check other tank Begin for T-44 70.2079 0.9 0.7593 Return cutted rate for T-44: 65.6277 Return middle rate of T-54: 67.96 Return middle rate of M46_Patton: 69.43 See other tank Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 Add good rate for Lorraine40t: 67.8068 Return middle rate of Lorraine40t: 66.57 See other tank Panther_II 57.1429 Add good rate for E-50: 56.3633 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for E-50: 69.4335 Return middle rate of E-50: 65.19 Begin for KV-5 79.4667 1 0.6042 Similar tanks: VK4502P 61.2000 E-75 78.3133 GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Check other tank Begin for VK4502P 61.2000 1 0.9304 Return cutted rate for VK4502P: 60.5087 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Add good rate for KV-5: 70.2102 See other tank GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 Add good rate for KV-5: 67.6335 Return middle rate of KV-5: 67.47 Begin for T-54 82.1918 0.8 0.4440 Return good rate for T-54: 67.9641 Begin for IS-3 67.7321 0.3 0.7525 Similar tanks: T32 74.3802 IS 54.9223 T29 66.6667 See other tank T32 74.3802 Add good rate for IS-3: 67.2046 See other tank IS 54.9223 Check other tank Begin for IS 54.9223 1 0.9081 Return cutted rate for IS: 54.4221 See other tank T29 66.6667 Check other tank Begin for T29 66.6667 1 0.7122 Return cutted rate for T29: 63.2470 Return middle rate of IS-3: 60.67 Begin for Object_212 80.3175 1 0.5079 Similar tanks: G_Tiger 79.8450 SU-14 70.2206 G_E 87.8906 See other tank G_Tiger 79.8450 Check other tank Begin for G_Tiger 79.8450 1 0.5083 Similar tanks: G_E 87.8906 M40M43 88.9412 SU-14 70.2206 See other tank G_E 87.8906 Check other tank Begin for G_E 87.8906 0.5 0.3218 Similar tanks: M40M43 88.9412 M12 53.6481 S-51 66.9421 See other tank M40M43 88.9412 Check other tank Begin for M40M43 88.9412 1 0.4659 Return cutted rate for M40M43: 76.0702 See other tank M12 53.6481 Check other tank Begin for M12 53.6481 0.8 1.2342 Return cutted rate for M12: 53.6481 See other tank S-51 66.9421 Check other tank Begin for S-51 66.9421 0.8 0.8145 Return cutted rate for S-51: 62.7175 Return middle rate of G_E: 63.61 See other tank M40M43 88.9412 Add good rate for G_Tiger: 76.0702 See other tank SU-14 70.2206 Check other tank Begin for SU-14 70.2206 1 0.7578 Return cutted rate for SU-14: 67.0683 Return middle rate of G_Tiger: 69.30 See other tank SU-14 70.2206 Add good rate for Object_212: 67.0683 See other tank G_E 87.8906 Add good rate for Object_212: 63.6106 Return middle rate of Object_212: 67.69 Begin for F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 0.8 0.7102 Return good rate for F10_AMX_50B: 74.7384 Begin for M46_Patton 84.3810 1 0.4412 Return good rate for M46_Patton: 69.4335 Begin for IS-7 77.8626 0.6 0.5423 Return good rate for IS-7: 66.5036 Begin for ISU-152 57.8035 1 0.8327 Return cutted rate for ISU-152: 56.5594 Begin for KV1 61.1789 0.8 1.0891 Return cutted rate for KV1: 60.2067 Begin for Hummel 59.9174 1 0.9457 Return cutted rate for Hummel: 59.5254 Begin for Ferdinand 73.7527 1 0.7955 Similar tanks: JagdTiger 66.3636 ISU-152 57.8035 T30 74.7312 See other tank JagdTiger 66.3636 Check other tank Begin for JagdTiger 66.3636 1 0.8163 Return cutted rate for JagdTiger: 63.9587 See other tank ISU-152 57.8035 Add good rate for Ferdinand: 56.5594 See other tank T30 74.7312 Check other tank Begin for T30 74.7312 1 0.7508 Return cutted rate for T30: 70.1898 Return middle rate of Ferdinand: 65.26 Begin for IS8 58.1858 1 1.1122 Return good rate for IS8: 58.1858 Begin for Maus 92.6009 1 0.2895 Similar tanks: E-100 82.8829 VK4502P 61.2000 E-75 78.3133 See other tank E-100 82.8829 Check other tank Begin for E-100 82.8829 1 0.3625 Similar tanks: E-75 78.3133 VK4502P 61.2000 GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Add good rate for E-100: 70.2102 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Add good rate for E-100: 60.5087 See other tank GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 Add good rate for E-100: 69.5950 Return middle rate of E-100: 66.90 See other tank VK4502P 61.2000 Add good rate for Maus: 60.5087 See other tank E-75 78.3133 Add good rate for Maus: 70.2102 Return middle rate of Maus: 67.10 Begin for T-44 70.2079 0.9 0.7593 Return good rate for T-44: 65.6277 Begin for M40M43 88.9412 1 0.4659 Return good rate for M40M43: 76.0702 Begin for PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.9558 1 0.7277 Return good rate for PzVIB_Tiger_II: 69.3771 Begin for Object_704 73.3161 1 0.8095 Similar tanks: T30 74.7312 JagdTiger 66.3636 AMX50_Foch 89.2617 See other tank T30 74.7312 Add good rate for Object_704: 70.1898 See other tank JagdTiger 66.3636 Add good rate for Object_704: 63.9587 See other tank AMX50_Foch 89.2617 Check other tank Begin for AMX50_Foch 89.2617 1 0.5740 Similar tanks: AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 T30 74.7312 T25_2 59.2233 See other tank AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 Check other tank Begin for AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 1 0.7558 Return cutted rate for AMX_AC_Mle1948: 69.5929 See other tank T30 74.7312 Add good rate for AMX50_Foch: 70.1898 See other tank T25_2 59.2233 Check other tank Begin for T25_2 59.2233 1 1.4583 Return cutted rate for T25_2: 59.2233 Return middle rate of AMX50_Foch: 69.18 Return middle rate of Object_704: 68.33 Begin for M103 62.4021 1 1.0292 Return good rate for M103: 62.4021 Begin for S-51 66.9421 0.8 0.8145 Return good rate for S-51: 62.7175 Begin for M48A1 81.9945 0.8 0.6110 Similar tanks: T-54 82.1918 M46_Patton 84.3810 Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 See other tank T-54 82.1918 Add good rate for M48A1: 67.9641 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for M48A1: 69.4335 See other tank Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 Add good rate for M48A1: 67.8068 Return middle rate of M48A1: 68.82 Begin for Ch01_Type59 75.3709 1 0.7966 Return good rate for Ch01_Type59: 71.7837 Begin for AMX_50_120 84.2623 1 0.6746 Similar tanks: F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 IS8 58.1858 AMX_50_100 83.2432 See other tank F10_AMX_50B 85.0746 Add good rate for AMX_50_120: 74.7384 See other tank IS8 58.1858 Add good rate for AMX_50_120: 58.1858 See other tank AMX_50_100 83.2432 Check other tank Begin for AMX_50_100 83.2432 0.8 0.6157 Similar tanks: IS8 58.1858 IS-3 67.7321 T32 74.3802 See other tank IS8 58.1858 Add good rate for AMX_50_100: 58.1858 See other tank IS-3 67.7321 Add good rate for AMX_50_100: 60.6664 See other tank T32 74.3802 Add good rate for AMX_50_100: 67.2046 Return middle rate of AMX_50_100: 64.39 Return middle rate of AMX_50_120: 68.44 Begin for Lorraine155_51 78.7004 1 0.7513 Similar tanks: Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 Lorraine155_50 74.5455 G_Panther 54.3307 See other tank Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 Check other tank Begin for Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 0.6 0.6678 Similar tanks: Lorraine155_50 74.5455 G_Panther 54.3307 M40M43 88.9412 See other tank Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Check other tank Begin for Lorraine155_50 74.5455 0.5 0.7644 Similar tanks: G_Panther 54.3307 AMX_13F3AM 75.7576 M41 64.1618 See other tank G_Panther 54.3307 Check other tank Begin for G_Panther 54.3307 0.5 1.3510 Return cutted rate for G_Panther: 53.7635 See other tank AMX_13F3AM 75.7576 Check other tank Begin for AMX_13F3AM 75.7576 1 0.7093 Return cutted rate for AMX_13F3AM: 71.4317 See other tank M41 64.1618 Check other tank Begin for M41 64.1618 1 0.9682 Return cutted rate for M41: 63.8671 Return middle rate of Lorraine155_50: 63.22 See other tank G_Panther 54.3307 Add good rate for Bat_Chatillon155: 53.7635 See other tank M40M43 88.9412 Add good rate for Bat_Chatillon155: 76.0702 Return middle rate of Bat_Chatillon155: 65.98 See other tank Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Add good rate for Lorraine155_51: 63.2167 See other tank G_Panther 54.3307 Add good rate for Lorraine155_51: 53.7635 Return middle rate of Lorraine155_51: 64.27 Begin for SU-14 70.2206 1 0.7578 Return good rate for SU-14: 67.0683 Begin for ARL_44 89.6552 0.6 0.3661 Similar tanks: KV1 61.1789 T29 66.6667 T32 74.3802 See other tank KV1 61.1789 Add good rate for ARL_44: 60.2067 See other tank T29 66.6667 Add good rate for ARL_44: 63.2470 See other tank T32 74.3802 Add good rate for ARL_44: 67.2046 Return middle rate of ARL_44: 64.26 Begin for G_Tiger 79.8450 1 0.5083 Return good rate for G_Tiger: 69.2995 Begin for G_E 87.8906 0.5 0.3218 Return good rate for G_E: 63.6106 Begin for G_Panther 54.3307 0.5 1.3510 Return good rate for G_Panther: 53.7635 Begin for Panther_II 57.1429 1 0.8894 Return good rate for Panther_II: 56.3633 Begin for VK4502P 61.2000 1 0.9304 Return good rate for VK4502P: 60.5087 Begin for GB24_Centurion_Mk3 83.4008 1 0.6182 Similar tanks: GB23_Centurion 76.8116 M46_Patton 84.3810 Lorraine40t 86.7021 See other tank GB23_Centurion 76.8116 Add good rate for GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 73.5927 See other tank M46_Patton 84.3810 Add good rate for GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 69.4335 See other tank Lorraine40t 86.7021 Add good rate for GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 66.5723 Return middle rate of GB24_Centurion_Mk3: 71.00 Begin for T32 74.3802 0.7 0.7960 Return good rate for T32: 67.2046 Begin for M12 53.6481 0.8 1.2342 Return good rate for M12: 53.6481 Begin for Pershing 70.4036 0.8 0.7973 Return good rate for Pershing: 65.2834 Begin for Bat_Chatillon25t 79.7235 0.7 0.6331 Return good rate for Bat_Chatillon25t: 67.8068 Begin for T29 66.6667 1 0.7122 Return good rate for T29: 63.2470 Begin for T28 72.4490 1 0.6476 Similar tanks: Ferdinand 73.7527 T95 64.4860 JagdTiger 66.3636 See other tank Ferdinand 73.7527 Add good rate for T28: 65.2616 See other tank T95 64.4860 Check other tank Begin for T95 64.4860 1 0.6930 Return cutted rate for T95: 60.8200 See other tank JagdTiger 66.3636 Add good rate for T28: 63.9587 Return middle rate of T28: 64.22 Begin for IS 54.9223 1 0.9081 Return good rate for IS: 54.4221 Begin for SU-101 62.5000 1 0.9995 Return cutted rate for SU-101: 62.4945 Begin for SU-152 59.7884 1 0.8176 Return cutted rate for SU-152: 58.3094 Begin for JagdPanther 59.5745 1 0.9993 Return cutted rate for JagdPanther: 59.5690 Begin for Lorraine40t 86.7021 0.8 0.5779 Return good rate for Lorraine40t: 66.5723 Begin for T30 74.7312 1 0.7508 Return good rate for T30: 70.1898 Begin for AMX_AC_Mle1948 73.6559 1 0.7558 Return good rate for AMX_AC_Mle1948: 69.5929 Begin for AMX_50_100 83.2432 0.8 0.6157 Return good rate for AMX_50_100: 64.3897 Begin for GB12_Conqueror 89.3855 1 0.5864 Return good rate for GB12_Conqueror: 69.5950 Begin for M41 64.1618 1 0.9682 Return good rate for M41: 63.8671 Begin for VK3002DB 67.6647 1 0.5747 Similar tanks: T20 63.2653 T-43 56.9343 Ch01_Type59 75.3709 See other tank T20 63.2653 Check other tank Begin for T20 63.2653 1 0.8682 Return cutted rate for T20: 61.9450 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Check other tank Begin for T-43 56.9343 1 0.6447 Return cutted rate for T-43: 54.6087 See other tank Ch01_Type59 75.3709 Add good rate for VK3002DB: 71.7837 Return middle rate of VK3002DB: 62.68 Begin for E-75 78.3133 0.9 0.6663 Return good rate for E-75: 70.2102 Begin for Lorraine155_50 74.5455 0.5 0.7644 Return good rate for Lorraine155_50: 63.2167 Begin for AMX50_Foch 89.2617 1 0.5740 Return good rate for AMX50_Foch: 69.1781 Begin for T20 63.2653 1 0.8682 Return good rate for T20: 61.9450 Begin for VK1602 68.2759 0.8 0.4846 Similar tanks: T_50_2 66.6667 T-50 76.9841 M5_Stuart 65.1786 See other tank T_50_2 66.6667 Check other tank Begin for T_50_2 66.6667 0.3 0.5828 Similar tanks: M24_Chaffee 80.7692 T-50 76.9841 M5_Stuart 65.1786 See other tank M24_Chaffee 80.7692 Check other tank Begin for M24_Chaffee 80.7692 1 0.7381 Return cutted rate for M24_Chaffee: 76.2367 See other tank T-50 76.9841 Check other tank Begin for T-50 76.9841 0.3 0.5351 Similar tanks: M5_Stuart 65.1786 M24_Chaffee 80.7692 Lorraine155_50 74.5455 See other tank M5_Stuart 65.1786 Check other tank Begin for M5_Stuart 65.1786 0.8 1.8061 Return cutted rate for M5_Stuart: 65.1786 See other tank M24_Chaffee 80.7692 Add good rate for T-50: 76.2367 See other tank Lorraine155_50 74.5455 Add good rate for T-50: 63.2167 Return middle rate of T-50: 65.66 See other tank M5_Stuart 65.1786 Add good rate for T_50_2: 65.1786 Return middle rate of T_50_2: 65.38 See other tank T-50 76.9841 Add good rate for VK1602: 65.6557 See other tank M5_Stuart 65.1786 Add good rate for VK1602: 65.1786 Return middle rate of VK1602: 64.13 Begin for GB23_Centurion 76.8116 0.9 0.8980 Return good rate for GB23_Centurion: 73.5927 Begin for T-43 56.9343 1 0.6447 Return good rate for T-43: 54.6087 Begin for AMX_13F3AM 75.7576 1 0.7093 Return good rate for AMX_13F3AM: 71.4317 Begin for JagdPzIV 55.8140 1 0.8086 Return cutted rate for JagdPzIV: 54.7455 Begin for M18_Hellcat 74.4186 0.5 0.7173 Similar tanks: T25_2 59.2233 JagdPanther 59.5745 JagdPzIV 55.8140 See other tank T25_2 59.2233 Add good rate for M18_Hellcat: 59.2233 See other tank JagdPanther 59.5745 Add good rate for M18_Hellcat: 59.5690 See other tank JagdPzIV 55.8140 Add good rate for M18_Hellcat: 54.7455 Return middle rate of M18_Hellcat: 59.14 Begin for T-50 76.9841 0.3 0.5351 Return good rate for T-50: 65.6557 Begin for VK3601H 57.9832 0.7 0.8503 Similar tanks: VK3001P 53.2710 T-34-85 67.3077 T-43 56.9343 See other tank VK3001P 53.2710 Check other tank Begin for VK3001P 53.2710 0.8 0.8555 Return cutted rate for VK3001P: 51.8538 See other tank T-34-85 67.3077 Check other tank Begin for T-34-85 67.3077 0.7 0.6243 Similar tanks: VK3001P 53.2710 T-43 56.9343 T20 63.2653 See other tank VK3001P 53.2710 Add good rate for T-34-85: 51.8538 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Add good rate for T-34-85: 54.6087 See other tank T20 63.2653 Add good rate for T-34-85: 61.9450 Return middle rate of T-34-85: 57.04 See other tank T-43 56.9343 Add good rate for VK3601H: 54.6087 Return middle rate of VK3601H: 54.65 Begin for GB11_Caernarvon 83.8983 0.8 0.5977 Return good rate for GB11_Caernarvon: 67.6335 Begin for T_50_2 66.6667 0.3 0.5828 Return good rate for T_50_2: 65.3839 Begin for M5_Stuart 65.1786 0.8 1.8061 Return good rate for M5_Stuart: 65.1786 Begin for E-100 82.8829 1 0.3625 Return good rate for E-100: 66.9038 Begin for JagdTiger 66.3636 1 0.8163 Return good rate for JagdTiger: 63.9587 Begin for T95 64.4860 1 0.6930 Return good rate for T95: 60.8200 Begin for VK3001P 53.2710 0.8 0.8555 Return good rate for VK3001P: 51.8538 Begin for T-34-85 67.3077 0.7 0.6243 Return good rate for T-34-85: 57.0378 Begin for M24_Chaffee 80.7692 1 0.7381 Return good rate for M24_Chaffee: 76.2367 Begin for T25_2 59.2233 1 1.4583 Return good rate for T25_2: 59.2233 Begin for Bat_Chatillon155 85.4369 0.6 0.6678 Return good rate for Bat_Chatillon155: 65.9760Begin winrate is: 73.78 rate T-rate Ka Kd Tank 88.46 66.17 0.5000 0.4803 T110 72.64 65.19 1.0000 0.7494 E-50 79.47 67.47 1.0000 0.6042 KV-5 82.19 67.96 0.8000 0.4440 T-54 67.73 60.67 0.3000 0.7525 IS-3 80.32 67.69 1.0000 0.5079 Object_212 85.07 74.74 0.8000 0.7102 F10_AMX_50B 84.38 69.43 1.0000 0.4412 M46_Patton 77.86 66.50 0.6000 0.5423 IS-7 57.80 56.56 1.0000 0.8327 ISU-152 61.18 60.21 0.8000 1.0891 KV1 59.92 59.53 1.0000 0.9457 Hummel 73.75 65.26 1.0000 0.7955 Ferdinand 58.19 58.19 1.0000 1.1122 IS8 92.60 67.10 1.0000 0.2895 Maus 70.21 65.63 0.9000 0.7593 T-44 88.94 76.07 1.0000 0.4659 M40M43 73.96 69.38 1.0000 0.7277 PzVIB_Tiger_II 73.32 68.33 1.0000 0.8095 Object_704 62.40 62.40 1.0000 1.0292 M103 66.94 62.72 0.8000 0.8145 S-51 81.99 68.82 0.8000 0.6110 M48A1 75.37 71.78 1.0000 0.7966 Ch01_Type59 84.26 68.44 1.0000 0.6746 AMX_50_120 78.70 64.27 1.0000 0.7513 Lorraine155_51 70.22 67.07 1.0000 0.7578 SU-14 89.66 64.26 0.6000 0.3661 ARL_44 79.84 69.30 1.0000 0.5083 G_Tiger 87.89 63.61 0.5000 0.3218 G_E 54.33 53.76 0.5000 1.3510 G_Panther 57.14 56.36 1.0000 0.8894 Panther_II 61.20 60.51 1.0000 0.9304 VK4502P 83.40 71.00 1.0000 0.6182 GB24_Centurion_Mk3 74.38 67.20 0.7000 0.7960 T32 53.65 53.65 0.8000 1.2342 M12 70.40 65.28 0.8000 0.7973 Pershing 79.72 67.81 0.7000 0.6331 Bat_Chatillon25t 66.67 63.25 1.0000 0.7122 T29 72.45 64.22 1.0000 0.6476 T28 54.92 54.42 1.0000 0.9081 IS 62.50 62.49 1.0000 0.9995 SU-101 59.79 58.31 1.0000 0.8176 SU-152 59.57 59.57 1.0000 0.9993 JagdPanther 86.70 66.57 0.8000 0.5779 Lorraine40t 74.73 70.19 1.0000 0.7508 T30 73.66 69.59 1.0000 0.7558 AMX_AC_Mle1948 83.24 64.39 0.8000 0.6157 AMX_50_100 89.39 69.59 1.0000 0.5864 GB12_Conqueror 64.16 63.87 1.0000 0.9682 M41 67.66 62.68 1.0000 0.5747 VK3002DB 78.31 70.21 0.9000 0.6663 E-75 74.55 63.22 0.5000 0.7644 Lorraine155_50 89.26 69.18 1.0000 0.5740 AMX50_Foch 63.27 61.94 1.0000 0.8682 T20 68.28 64.13 0.8000 0.4846 VK1602 76.81 73.59 0.9000 0.8980 GB23_Centurion 56.93 54.61 1.0000 0.6447 T-43 75.76 71.43 1.0000 0.7093 AMX_13F3AM 55.81 54.75 1.0000 0.8086 JagdPzIV 74.42 59.14 0.5000 0.7173 M18_Hellcat 76.98 65.66 0.3000 0.5351 T-50 57.98 54.65 0.7000 0.8503 VK3601H 83.90 67.63 0.8000 0.5977 GB11_Caernarvon 66.67 65.38 0.3000 0.5828 T_50_2 65.18 65.18 0.8000 1.8061 M5_Stuart 82.88 66.90 1.0000 0.3625 E-100 66.36 63.96 1.0000 0.8163 JagdTiger 64.49 60.82 1.0000 0.6930 T95 53.27 51.85 0.8000 0.8555 VK3001P 67.31 57.04 0.7000 0.6243 T-34-85 80.77 76.24 1.0000 0.7381 M24_Chaffee 59.22 59.22 1.0000 1.4583 T25_2 85.44 65.98 0.6000 0.6678 Bat_Chatillon155Corrected winrate is: 65.00Duration: 50ms Хотелось бы конечно знать - временное это явление или новая политика ВГ. Иначе может получиться, что все хитрые формулы с дамагом пойдут на свалку. Надо спрашивать у кого-то, приближенного к разрабам. У меня таких контактов нет, к сожалению. Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
13 Posted January 2, 2013 Share Posted January 2, 2013 Надо спрашивать у кого-то, приближенного к разрабам. Бесполезно. Когда я играл в WoT я иногда общался(играл) с несколькими разработчиками, и каждый из них на один и тот же вопрос давал разный ответ. Многие из них абсолютно не в курсе реального положения дел :) Я думаю для решения проблем с API есть один путь: написать подробный багрепорт в саппорт и поддерживать дальнейшую переписку со школьниками операторами саппорта до тех пор, пока они перестанут отвечать копипастами и передадут запрос вышестоящей администрации. Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
sirmax Posted January 2, 2013 Share Posted January 2, 2013 Знаю, я сперва даже делал более сложный расчет, чтобы этого избежать. Но потом счел, что простота и быстродействие важнее.Порядок обхода сейчас правильный - начиная с танков, на которых больше всего боев. Они ведь и на статистику влияют больше, следовательно их нужно посчитать точнее. Сейчас сортировки нет - обрабатывается в том порядке, в каком отдает WG. Сделать сортировку по кол-ву боев? Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
tourist Posted January 2, 2013 Author Share Posted January 2, 2013 Сейчас сортировки нет - обрабатывается в том порядке, в каком отдает WG.Сделать сортировку по кол-ву боев? ВГ отдает уже в отсортированном порядке - так что разве на всякий случай можно воткнуть. Где нужна сортировка - так это в порядке сравнения танков, желательно, чтобы в первую очередь сравнивало с самым похожим. А так выглядит вполне ничего - что будем с этим делать дальше? Будет страничка, где можно будет потыкаться и потестить расчет? Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
sirmax Posted January 2, 2013 Share Posted January 2, 2013 (edited) ВГ отдает уже в отсортированном порядке - так что разве на всякий случай можно воткнуть. Тогда пока не буду делать, чтобы не усложнять расчет. Но надо будет за этим понаблюдать. Где нужна сортировка - так это в порядке сравнения танков, желательно, чтобы в первую очередь сравнивало с самым похожим. Так и сделано. А так выглядит вполне ничего - что будем с этим делать дальше? Будет страничка, где можно будет потыкаться и потестить расчет? Сейчас посмотрю как малыми усилиями это сделать. Заодно надо прикрутить к нашей БД. Прикрутил к нашему тестовому сервису, пока только через cmd-api (то есть в базу ничего не пишется). Данные берутся из нашей БД (могут быть не совсем актуальными - в пределах недели). Пример: http://proxy.bulychev.net:1333/?0,TWR,FnB FnB - имя пользователя, можно подставлять любое. Вот по туристу: http://proxy.bulychev.net:1333/?0,TWR,tourist1984 Сервис запущен вручную, так что может перестать работать, если я его буду править. Скрипты тут: http://code.google.com/p/wot-xvm/source/browse/#svn%2Ftrunk%2Fsrc%2Fnodejs-xvm-proxy%2Ftcalc Имя пользователя регистрозависимое. Edited January 2, 2013 by sirmax Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yupi Posted January 2, 2013 Share Posted January 2, 2013 (edited) Begin winrate is: 57.29 Corrected winrate is: 0.00 Проверил ike_a Edited January 2, 2013 by TwoPizza Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
sirmax Posted January 2, 2013 Share Posted January 2, 2013 Begin winrate is: 57.29Corrected winrate is: 0.00 Проверил ike_a Дамага нет. Надо будет заглушку поставить. Link to comment Short link Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts